Comparison of chisel tine draft requirements using analytical, experimental, and numerical methods
In this study, the draft requirement of a chisel tine was investigated using analytical, experimental and numerical methods. The modified Mckyes-Ali equation and the ASABE D497.7 standard equation were used as analytical approaches. In the experimental part, 48 treatments based on a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with four forward speeds (1.8, 2.3, 2.9, and 3.5 km/h), three depths (30, 40, and 50 cm), and four replications were studied in the field. The coupled Eulerian- Lagrangian analysis method in ABAQUS software was used as a finite element method (FEM) in the numerical part. Draft requirements obtained by FEM, Mckyes-Ali, and ASABE approaches were compared with field tests. Field results showed that the draft requirement is greatly influenced by forward speed, tillage depth, and their interaction (P < 0.01). The ASABE equation, the Mckyes-Ali equation, and the FEM approach predicted the field results with poor (difference < 33.2%), good (difference < 7%), and excellent (difference < 3.3%, except for 2 cases) accuracy, respectively. A paired sample T-test showed that only the difference between the FEM results and the field data was not significant (sig = 0.263). Therefore, FEM as a numerical approach can be used to simulate and analyze the forces caused by the interaction between soil and tillage tines. Moreover, the FEM results showed that the minimum predicted draft requirement of the chisel tine within the investigated numerical conditions would be obtained at a blade rake angle of 15°.
Read more here: Source link
